Bahama Breeze Dessert Menu: Is the Key Lime Pie Actually Worth It?
Three desserts, one clear favorite, and whether you should save room even when you’re stuffed.
The Bahama Breeze dessert menu has three options — Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie ($10.49), Chocolate Island ($10.99), and Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake ($11.49) — plus a Whole Key Lime Pie to take home for $36.99. The Key Lime Pie is the most consistently recommended dessert and is big enough to split between two or three people.
We almost skipped dessert every single time we’ve eaten here, mostly out of habit — starters plus an entrée usually leaves us full. The one time we didn’t skip it, the Key Lime Pie changed our minds permanently. It’s tart in the way key lime pie is supposed to be (not the overly sweet version a lot of chains serve), and one slice comfortably covers two people if you’ve already eaten a full meal.
Full dessert menu
| Item | Calories | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie Signature | ~1,050 cal | $10.49 |
| Chocolate Island | ~1,040 cal | $10.99 |
| Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake | ~1,380 cal | $11.49 |
Take-home option
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Whole Key Lime Pie (family-style, serves several) | $36.99 |
Which dessert to order
Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie is the one to get if you only try one dessert here — it’s the most talked-about item on the whole dessert menu and lives up to the reputation. Flaming Pineapple Butter Cake has the highest calorie count on the list, so it’s the pick if you want something bigger and richer to split as a table. Chocolate Island is the safest choice if key lime or pineapple flavors aren’t your thing and you just want a solid chocolate dessert.
FAQ
What’s the best dessert at Bahama Breeze?
Rebecca’s Key Lime Pie is the most consistently recommended dessert on the menu.
How much is Bahama Breeze dessert?
Individual desserts run $10.49–$11.49, and a whole Key Lime Pie to take home is $36.99.
Can I order a whole Key Lime Pie to go?
Yes, the Whole Key Lime Pie is available as a family-style take-home option for $36.99.
Want the full menu with every price?
See every starter, entrée, drink and dessert price on the complete Bahama Breeze menu guide.
See the full menu & prices →